« February 2008 | Main | April 2008 »

AltSearchEngines: A Chat About OrganizedWisdom with Unity Stoakes

I conducted the following interview with AltSearchEngines.com last week.  Click here to read the complete interview on their blog, but here are some of the highlights:

ASE: OrganizedWisdom Health is an innovative approach to the online search for health info. Can you please talk about what OW is and how the concept was developed/refined?

Unity Stoakes: OrganizedWisdom Health is a human-powered, doctor-guided search service for health. We have a team of expert guides and physician reviewers who create WisdomCards to help people find the best health information, products and services on the Web. We are laying the knowledge, experience, and credibility of experts on top of great technologies to guide people to health resources that will help them.

The concept for OrganizedWisdom.com was developed as a result of our own frustration with health search. A few years ago, my business partner Steven Krein was searching for very specific health information when he and his wife were trying to have their first child. After searching for many hours, they still weren’t able to find the information they needed. What they did find was a lot of clutter, random user generated content and spam Web sites that now get mixed in with all the quality resources. After discussing the problem, we realized there had to be a better way to draw on the collective wisdom of experts, health advocates and doctors, to help filter out the junk. We decided to create a service that guides people to the very best info, resources and services.

So far OrganizedWisdom.com has created WisdomCards for over 15,000 of the most popular health search terms and we plan to cover over 200,000 health topics in the next 24 months for all health topics including diseases, conditions, treatments, drugs, holistic topics, lifestyle issues, and even doctors and hospitals.

ASE: Tell us about the challenge of running a health/medical search engine. It would seem there are more legal issues when people are searching for medical info.

Unity Stoakes: The legal issues are actually not our main concern because we are very clear that we do not provide medical advice and we do recommend people see a doctor immediately if they have an important health issue. Our focus, and main priority, is on quality and credibility. Our goal is to make each WisdomCard exceptional and it must meet very strict guidelines. People often ask how we maintain all of these WisdomCards and how this model can scale. We are able to leverage great collaboration technology, and a distributed team of Guides and Experts, to make this possible. By laying human knowledge with the power of great technology and social media, these challenges become very manageable.

ASE: Was there a steep learning curve for you (re: medical information) when you founded OW?

Unity Stoakes: Many of the people on our team are doctors and health experts. We also make sure to have people working on our team who have been patient advocates and understand the needs from the perspective of people living with a disease or health issue. We do see it as an advantage that when we started the company, we were not health professionals, however, because it gave us the opportunity to think with a fresh perspective. We often meet people who have been in the health care industry for years and they are jaded, or constantly saying why something can’t be done, or how long it will take to fix. Our approach is to think about how it can be fixed — and how we can start making a difference now. We’re trying to look at it from the perspective of a real person needing care or information. We think about the way we want health search to work for us and our families.

ASE: How is searching with OW different than other search engines that provide medical information?

Unity Stoakes: No one really needs 1.4 million Web pages when you type in a health query. People want an organized set of links that guide them to the very best information and resources they can trust. People credible sites and answer their questions. Because our WisdomCards are created by health experts, we are able to filter out all of the junk, clutter, and index spam and guide people to the very best evidence based resources and even user-generated content. We have experts looking at every resource and we are the only doctor-guided search service on the Web.

ASE: What are the most popular wisdom cards/searches?

Unity Stoakes: In the past few minutes we had people search on cancer, ovarian cysts, sexually transmitted diseases, famous people who died of aids, depression, care-giving advice. There is a great variety of health topics that people are searching for and we are seeing many very “long tail” topics. The trends change each hour and very often can be impacted by cultural events, news media, the weather, the season, etc. People often have very specific health issues they are searching for and it can be difficult for them to find credible information in some areas.

ASE: What is “Live Wisdom?”

Unity Stoakes: LiveWisdom is a new service we are building into WisdomCards so people can connect LIVE via chat with board certified doctors, health professionals, and health advocates for only $1.99 per minute. We believe that asking doctors questions should be easy, affordable, and accessible to all. The service is not meant to be a doctor visit, but is meant to be an educational resource for people who may have one or two important questions. The service, still in pilot beta, is private and anonymous as well which we think will help a lot of people get information they otherwise may avoid asking.

ASE: I know that your Wisdomcards are ‘handcrafted.’ Can you please explain what that means- who crafts them? Is that different than other medical web search engines?

Unity Stoakes: Each WisdomCard features an organized set of links that have been reviewed and placed their by a an expert guide who we pay. Other health search engines either use technology algorithms to display their links or they feature licensed content from one of a few evidence-based information providers. Our expert guides are health advocates, patient experts, web researchers, nurses, health professionals, and doctors. We pay people to handcraft WisdomCards because we think that health information is too important to leave to technology alone. We believe that our service approach layered on top of great algorithms is more powerful because our trained experts can actually check each resource to make sure it is useful, credible, and worthy of inclusion on a WisdomCard.

ASE: How much marketing do you do/ what’s your target demographic?

Unity Stoakes: We don’t spend money on marketing actually. We focus all of our energy and resources on creating quality WisdomCards — our content. We are generating most of our traffic from search engines like Google, Yahoo and MSN as well as hospitals, health foundations and bloggers who link to our WisdomCards. Our target demographic is anyone seeking health information. About 80% of internet users have searched for health information so it is a very wide demographic. Originally, more women used the site, but it is getting closer to 50/50 now. And the majority of users are between the ages of 25 and 54. But you would be surprised at how many younger people are using the site.

ASE: Who inspires you in the business sector? Personally? Why?

Unity Stoakes: We are big fans of the team at 37Signals and their approach to innovation. Their book Getting Real has been like our business bible. We have learned a lot from them in trying to keep things simple and constantly working to improve our service. Personally, Richard Branson is also a big influence because he is willing to take on any challenge no matter how big — the bigger the better — and fight against the established status quo. We admire people who think big and go big — and never give up.

ASE: When I’m not working I’m….

Unity Stoakes: Hmmm… Is that a trick question? Actually, the truth is we don’t feel like what we are doing is work at all. It is a mission to us. Building OrganizedWisdom is not only fun, but it is immensely rewarding especially when people email you or tell you how much you have helped them.

ASE: Whom are you rooting for in this election?

Unity Stoakes: It is too early to tell. The health platforms have been fairly vague. And our honest belief is that it is going to be up to entrepreneurs and consumers to change health care. We don’t have time to wait for politicians anymore.

ASE: Where do you think medical/health search will be in one year?

Unity Stoakes: Many more people will realize the value of having doctor-guided search. It will be embedded into your hospitals web page, your health foundations web site, and if you have a smart doctor into their personal blog. Sound too dreamy? Not if we have anything to do about it…

Rave Review: AltSearchEngines.com Loves OrganizedWisdom

One of our favorite blogs, AltSearchEngines.com, published a rave review this weekend titled: Why I Heart Health Search Engine OrganizedWisdom.

Our dedicated team of Expert Guides work incredibly hard to make sure we deliver great service to thousands of people each day so it is great to get this kind of recognition for something you are really proud of. You can read the full review from the link above, but here's how the post ends:

Bottom line: If you want a WisdomCard for your medical condition, or for your friend or family member’s, OW will either have one or make one. And if you have a question about it, you can check in with your personal Health Expert.

Honestly, can Google do that?

Summer Interns: We Want You!

OrganizedWisdom is now accepting applications now for 3 Summer Intern positions. 

We're looking for super-smart, innovative, and dedicated students who want to help us build the world's first doctor-powered search service for health.

If you are passionate about learning, getting involved in lots of aspects of growing a company, and care about trying to help people get better health information, then get in touch with us.

We're looking for great writers, researchers, web designers, online community experts, business leaders, and of course med-students.

The best part of this internship is that because we have a virtual online office, you can work from anywhere you have dedicated Internet access and a computer.  No need to live in NYC to apply.  You'll be a full-time member of our team and fully integrated via our online collaboration systems, working with the team daily.

HOW TO APPLY:

Submit your resume (career AT organizedwisdom DOT com) or better yet send us your facebook/twitter/myspace, etc. with a note about why you're a superstar, your areas of expertise and what you hope to get our of an internship with OrganizedWisdom.

Healthcare in a Health 2.0 World and Personalized Genomic Health

Just wanted to let you know about two great upcoming speaking engagements we are speaking at in the next two weeks. One is this week for the Harvard Business School Alumni Association and one is in two weeks where my partner Steven Krein is on a panel with John Doerr, Dean Ornish, MD and David Agus MD.

We hope we get a chance to see you in person at one or both of these events:

Personalized Genomic Health: New Paradigms, New Industry for Navigenics
Thursday, April 10th at 6pm with the John Doerr from Kleiner Perkins, Dean Ornish, MD and David Agus MD.  For more information: http://www.navigenics.com/dnanyc/apr_10.html
Harvard Business School Alumni Association:  "Healthcare in a Health 2.0 World"
Thursday, March 27th at 5:30 with 4 other great panelists including Jacob Goldstein from Wall Street Journal, Craig DeLarge from Novo Nordisk, and John Fedelino from Interbrand Wood Healthcare.  For more info: http://www.hbshealth.org/whatsnew.cfm?CFID=6869878&CFTOKEN=25483#bunny

Interbrandwoodhealthcare_2

WIRED Says To Search Smarter, Use a Person

The human-guided search trend continues to gain traction as more companies are integrating the power of human intelligence with great technology.

Now the mainstream press has finally gotten around to covering the trend.  Newsweek featured a piece on the rise of the expert a week ago, and here's a great read from WIRED:

"Algorithms Are Terrific. But to Search Smarter Find a Person."

Getting Vertical Search Right: The Future of Search is Service

Logotop Just about to head over to SES right now.  Steven Krein is speaking on the main stage this afternoon about Getting Vertical Search Right.

We'll be presenting on our strong belief that the future of search is SERVICE.

At OrganizedWisdom Health we realized when we launched that when people are searching for something as important as health information, abundance is not what they are looking for.  Service is.  Most people want information, links, and resources they know they can trust.  It's no longer about getting back 1.4 million search results in .09 seconds.  People want to be guided to a few of the very best links on the topic they are searching for.  People want vetted information, curated links.  Not just a big heap of Web pages with relevant key words and lots of links in/out.

This is where the concept of service comes in.  There are great search services developing that are layering experts, and the power of human guides, onto the world's best search technologies.  Mahalo is an example of a general human-powered search service covering popular search topics from video games to entertainment news.  ChaCha is an example of a general search service where experts will help you via live chat or text.   SeamlessWeb helps people search local restaurants and place orders for delivery.  And OrganizedWisdom (what many have dubbed the Mahalo of Health) is a search service using experts and doctors to guide people to the very best health information and resources.

We believe that as a result of abundance (too many web sites, too many spammers, too many marketers, too many offers, too much information, too many options), there is going to be a powerful service infrastructure that gets built on top of search technologies.

Let me give you two key examples of services we have layered into the search experience and offer at OrganizedWisdom Health.

Last year we launched RequestWisdom - a free service where anyone can request a WisdomCard on any health topic.  If we don't already have the requested WisdomCard created, one of our expert Guides will build the WisdomCard and send the results to the person and publish for all other searchers benefit.  We do the searching for the user.  The good news is that most of the time, our team has already created a WisdomCard on the requested topic and our library of WisdomCards is growing every day (now have over 10,000 health searches covered).  But by adding a free service onto our already running human-powered search service, we are able to deliver specific, clutter-free and organized results that our community needs.

Another example of layering service into search is the new service we are testing in private beta and rolling out site wide soon.  It's called LiveWisdom, and enables anyone to chat LIVE with a doctor to ask questions for $1.99 a minute.  It's an anonymous service and easy to use.  We're adding the service of speaking with a doctor in real-time during the search experience.  We believe that connecting with a doctor should be easy, affordable, and accessible by all.  By adding this service into our search process, we make this a reality.

We'll be talking about these examples and many others today along with an incredible panel of experts.  We hope this spurs a great discussion and others begin to think of new ways to integrate service into search.

Panel Details:

Orion Panel: Getting Vertical Search Right
The need for specialized search capabilities has never been more prevalent than it is today. Established leaders and experts in vertical search application and execution will discuss the state of the industry, positive and negative experiences and best practices for answering needs of today's demanding searchers.

Moderator:
     
Speakers:

Newsweek: UGC Pendulum Swings to Info Vetted by Experts

Tried to search blog posts recently in Technorati?  Or find the best videos on YouTube? Or how about just searching Google to answer an important health question?

It's getting more and more difficult as a result of the millions of Web pages, blogs, and videos being posted by millions of Amateurs - the so called crowd.  This is an issue we've been speaking about for more than two years now at OrganizedWisdom so you can bet we were happy to see the most recent issue of Newsweek highlighting the "expert" powered movement online.

The article titled, Revenge of the Experts: The individual user has been king on the Internet, but the pendulum seems to be swinging back toward edited information vetted by professionals, picks up on the fact that user-generated content created by amateurs has flooded the Internet.

In short, the expert is back. The revival comes amid mounting demand for a more reliable, bankable Web. "People are beginning to recognize that the world is too dangerous a place for faulty information," says Charlotte Beal, a consumer strategist for the Minneapolis-based research firm Iconoculture. Beal adds that choice fatigue and fear of bad advice are creating a "perfect storm of demand for expert information."

Perhaps no area of the Web is this issue more important than with health information which is why we've been focused on using the power of experts to curate the best health information.   Not only do people want to know that the health information they read online is credible, but they don't want to have to wade through a haystack to find the best nuggets.

We're not sure that the wisdom of the crowds is even close to peaking, but we couldn't agree more with this quote from Mahalo founder Jason Calacanis that helps end the piece: "Web 3.0 is taking what we've built in Web 2.0—the wisdom of the crowds—and putting an editorial layer on it of truly talented, compensated people to make the product more trusted and refined."

Expect to see the power of human guides, experts, and new service layers become more integrated into many of the most successful user-generated content sites.

OrganizedWisdom Online Store

We got a few requests recently for OrganizedWisdom T-shirts, mugs and the like so we thought we'd do the Web 2.0 thing and throw up a quick little online store on Cafe Press.  It's easy, fast, and let's us focus on what we do best: organizing the world's health resources.

We haven't marked up any of the products so if you want one of those T-shirts with a big juicy OW apple on it, you'll be getting it at the Cafe Press cost.

Check out the store here.

Speaking at Search Engine Strategies, HBS, and EconHealth Conference

OrganizedWisdom will be presenting on four more great health care panels this month. We're looking forward to the range of topics and issues being discussed. We'll blog what we can and hope to see you there...

Monday, March 17, 2008 NYC - Search Engine Strategies 2008: Getting Vertical Search Right

Thursday, March 20, 2008 NYC - EconHealth Conference: Emerging Models: HealthContent & Web 2.0

Thursday, March 20, 2008 NYC - Search Engine Strategies 2008: My Search is Better than Your Search

Thursday, March 27, 2008 NYC -  Harvard Business School Health Industry Alumni Association: Healthcare in a Web 2.0 World

 

Steven Krein ICYou Video Interview at Health 2.0 Conference

VentureBeat Features OrganizedWisdom at Health 2.0

We're happy to be one of only six companies from more than 50 attending Health 2.0 to be featured in David Hamilton's VentureBeat post today titled: Six Health 2.0 firms reinvent doctor-patient ties.

Here's a snippet from the post:

OrganizedWisdom already has an established presence in Health 2.0 with its “human-powered” medical search engine, a Mahalo-like attempt to bring expert attention to search requests. The startup essentially lets people search through precompiled “wisdom cards,” each vetted by medical experts, that list reliable resources on diseases and drugs along with recent news headlines, treatment alternatives, support groups and message boards, and research findings.

OrganizedWisdom now plans to supplement that information with a new service it calls Live Wisdom, in which anyone can chat online with a medical professional for $1.99 a minute. CEO Steve Krein demonstrated what he described as an actual chat between a patient just diagnosed with laryngeal cancer and a doctor, in which the two discussed treatment options and probable outcomes — and even the physician’s response when the patient asked, “Am I going to die?” (The cure rate for an early-stage cancer turns out to be pretty good, the doctor replied.)

Click here to read the complete article and learn about Carol, Myca, AmericanWell, Phreesia, and Pharma Surveyor.

OrganizedWisdom Introduces LiveWisdom: Connecting People with Doctors Should be Easy, Affordable, and Accessible to All

We've just returned from the second Health 2.0 conference that took place in San Diego earlier this week.  It was a tremendous event with standing room only, as was to be expected given Indu Subaiya and Matthew Holt organized it. 

Over 30 companies presented and hundreds more attended.  The networking was fantastic and we were happy to meet with so many other thought leaders, friends and colleagues in the Health 2.0 world.  Some highlights included Esther Dyson showing us 23andMe in action, spending quality time with Adam Bosworth (formally Google Health now Keas.com), participating in the Unconference, announcing the dCard at the Health 2.0 Accelerator, learning more from Susannah Fox, working with IDEO, catching up with Craig Stoltz, finally meeting David Hamilton from Venture Beat in person, doing video interviews with ICYou.com crew, finalizing details with Cheryl Greene from DrGreene.com, convos with Scott Schreve David Kibbe, and Enoch Choi, hearing from Josh Seidman that the next Information Therapy Conference will be in DC, and having drinks with East Coast friends Bill Allman from Health CentralNetwork, Paul Gollash from Virgin, Jack Barrette from WEGOHealth, Jay Parkinson from Myca. The list goes on and on...

But the highlight for us was presenting LiveWisdom for the first time.   

On stage with AmericanWell and Jay Parkinson, OrganizedWisdom demoed something we are extremely excited about and believe will help change health care forever.  We launched LiveWisdom, a new Live Chat and Email service that is currently in a beta pilot and will soon be integrated on all of our WisdomCards.

LiveWisdom enables people to chat LIVE and anonymously with a board-certified doctor, health professional or health advocate for only a $1.99 a minute.  Yep, $1.99 a minute.  We are brining micro payments to health care so that anyone (insured or not) can at least ask a doctor a question when they need to.  LiveWisdom is embedded directly into WisdomCards so that people can ask important questions or get additional information directly related to the health topics they are searching on at the time.  It's that simple. 

We believe that connecting with doctors should be easy, affordable, and accessible to all.  There are millions of people who have questions they need answered quickly, privately, and from the convenience of their own home.  LiveWisdom is not meant to replace a doctor visit, like the service AmericanWell will provide, but people often have important questions that a live chat with a doctor could quickly answer.  If more information or an actual visit to a doctor is required then we can refer people to American Well, Myca,  a local mediclinic, hospital or doctor depending on the situation.

(Click to read what VentureBeat had to say about our new service).

In the coming weeks, we will be expanding the service and integrating LiveWisdom into all of our WisdomCards so that people who are searching for important health information will now have access to a doctor.  If you are a board-certified doctor or health professional and are interested in joining our LiveWisdom program please contact us at info at organizedwisdom dot com.

Who is OrganizedWisdom?

  • OrganizedWisdom is on a mission to organize the world’s best health wisdom. With your help and a team of expert Health Guides, we are organizing and reviewing the very best health content from across the Web so you can find great health information from credible sources.
  • OrganizedWisdom was started by serial entrepreneurs Steven Krein and Unity Stoakes. Steven Krein and Unity Stoakes are located in New York City, along with our Medical Director, Scott Pearlman, M.D. Our editor, Pat Washburn, is in Wells, Maine, and Chief Medical Officer, Howard Krein, M.D., Ph.D is in Philadelphia, Pa. With an innovative team of developers, designers, Guides and physicians, we're working to bring you a health resource you can use every day.

    Contact Us about any press inquiries, partnership opportunities, general questions, comments, and feedback.

Additional Information

Blogs

Google

Visit organizedwisdom.com